By Kiara Bhatia
Today, in anticipation of the 2024 Paris Olympics, the European Parliamentary Research Service (EPRS) released their 2024 International Women's Day research report on gender inequality in professional sports leadership. While significant progress has been made towards gender equality in sports over the past decade, the report points out that one area of gender disparity that still persists is the lack of women in sports governance positions. Only 32% of the International Olympics Committee members are women, and just 31% of professional European sports coaches are female, based on a sample of 18 European countries. By the end of last year, men held 78% of top decision-making positions in the national EU federations of the 10 most popular sports.
Having female representation in sports leadership is important for a variety of reasons. Female leaders
provide diverse perspectives and give women a voice in sports-related decision making. Additionally, they inspire young girls and women to get involved in sports and envision new possibilities of themselves in leadership positions.
Why do you think this gender disparity exists and what are some possible solutions to increase female leadership in sports?
Sources:
https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/ATAG/2024/759597/EPRS_ATA(2024)759597_EN.pdf
https://thechoice.escp.eu/choose-to-lead/taking-up-the-field-as-women-the-question-of-gender-equality-in-sports/
I think your point that the lack of women in leadership positions makes it hard for women to envision themselves in those roles is extremely challenging. I think one solution that could really have a great impact, because there are a ton of really important women in sports today, is having some sort of mentorship program. I think once there are these networks being created for women in sports to share experiences and strategies, and people start investing in leadership development programs for women, the floodgates will open. This stat is not where it should be but, in 2021 there were 6 female coaches in the NFL, and in 2022 there were 15! Although a small number, that is a big jump, and I think we will start to see that number going up more and more in the coming years.
ReplyDeleteI like your idea about a mentorship program to help create a network for women in sports leadership. I also agree that a lot of progress has been made in the past few years with the industry and it's only continuing in the right direction. Even in the sports media world, seeing people like Jenny Cavnar becoming the lead play-by-play for the A's is really exciting and is offering glimpses of hope for women in all aspects of the sports industry.
DeleteI think that is a great idea actually. A lot of research shows that having strong and representative role models tends to inspire underrepresented groups such as women in sports leadership. The trend of an increase in female leaders is something that this report actually points out. Obviously change takes time, therefore hopefully the numbers of female leaders in sports continues to increase in the following years.
DeleteI think there is a lot of reasons for why these gender disparity exists. Like you said I think having a lack of representation in sports leadership can discourage young women from aspiring such roles. However women want to be in these positions but I think societal expectations and stereotypes about gender roles have historically limited women's involvement in leadership in positions, specifically in the male dominated world of sports. Another reason I believe gender disparity still exists is the gender bias and discrimination. Both implicit biases and overt discrimination effect women from getting into leadership positions. I think that women entering the sports world has continued to grow and will continue to grow but there needs to be more solutions to finally have an equal playing field. One solution which is the evident one but needs to be implemented is promoting diversity and inclusion and actively promoting a culture of diversity and inclusion which can help create a more welcoming environment. Another solution is mentorship and sponsorship programs which can help women access guidance and opportunities for career advancement.
ReplyDeleteI agree, and on top of the stereotypes regarding women in leadership positions, I think part of this inequality has to do with sports in society being painted as "manly". I have noticed that the girls clothing and toy sections of department stores tend to have princesses and beauty-related products, while the boys sections sell sports-related clothing, strong action figures, jerseys, and athletic gear. This social conditioning that starts as such a young age teaches women that sports are a "man's game", and they therefore often end up not exploring sports-related interests or entering leadership positions in the business of sports.
DeleteIt is very clear that gender disparity does exist within the sports industry. Women are constantly recognized/seen at lower rates than men in almost every area of sport (players, leadership, fans, media, etc.). I think this is an issue that will take a lot of time and effort within the entire sporting culture. One solution could be implementing quotas in leadership positions that a certain percentage needs to be women. although this can be seen an controversial I think they may be a good first step to bringing women into the sport industry and promoting female involvement.
ReplyDeleteI think a quota is actually a viable solution. There are likely many women who are qualified for leadership positions but are discouraged by the lack of diversity or have just not been considered. Creating a quota would help open up more leadership opportunities for these women and allow future generations of women to feel more encouraged to step into these positions.
DeleteSports began with working class men, so while it is disappointing, it is not a surprise that women are still not represented in the industry to the extent that men are. The sports industry is so male-dominated, both in leadership and in the media coverage, fans, and players, so it is important to look at ways to increase the female presence and keep women in these positions. Equal opportunity policies, like quotas and decreasing the wage gap, can help to improve the number of women in the industry and also work to keep them there. Also, many sports leadership positions, like coaching, can be challenging for women due to their expected role as a caregiver, so it is important to look at policies that can help increase flexibility with hours and providing childcare.
ReplyDeleteThe possibility of discrimination due to the dilemmas women face when trying to maintain a career while also having a family is an interesting point. Jobs like coaching are very time consuming and not easily replaceable, and coaches are expected to be with their teams all year-round. I therefore think it is not unlikely that women are not seen as as desirable as men for these positions due to the possibility of needing maternity leave. I therefore agree that many of the policies that have been placed into workspaces to support working women (such as flexible hours and childcare support) must be well-implemented in the sports industry so that women don't feel like they have to choose between having a career and having a family.
DeleteThe gender disparity in sports is disappointing, yet not surprising. Historically, gender stereotypes and traditional expectations of women vs. men created a strong barrier for opportunities for women to be involved in sports early on. This still echoes today, as women have had much further to climb to make it to where men even started. Additionally, because women didn't start off with equal representation, it made it difficult for women to see those roles as an option. When women don't see other women in leadership roles within sports, it creates the perception that those roles are not available to them. Further, there has always been bias and discriminatory practices in hiring, promotion, and pay that have limited women. To address these concerns, I think it's important for sports organizations to actively look to increase female representation and create a welcoming environment for women. Education on gender biases and training on how to avoid those can also help build awareness for the current situation. I think its very important for organizations to take on the goal of increasing representation, as it would not only help women, but sports as a whole.
ReplyDeleteI think the trend of historical inequality having lasting modern effects is something that affects many marginalized groups besides women. Because sports began with working class men, but was often most accessible to wealthy white families- especially males- women, racial minorities and low-income communities did not have the same opportunities to participate in sports. Unsurprisingly, these are the same groups that remain underrepresented in leadership positions. I therefore agree that this is an issue that has to be more holistically observed so that this representation is increased and a wider range of diverse perspectives participates in positions of power in sports.
DeleteThe Gender issue in sports leadership has stems from the bias and historical inequalities in sports. To help fix this issue I think that we need to make quotas on each team on how many woman must be apart of the organization. We need to provide mentorship, networking opportunities, and finally we need to try and make it desirable for woman to want to join the industry. By doing this I believe that it will pave a way for young females to join the sports world.
ReplyDeleteI thought about the solution of quotas too. It seems like a great idea. However, in many other industries where race of gender-based quotas were implemented (such as affirmative action in U.S. colleges), there has been a lot of backlash where people have argued that those hired for leadership positions are not qualified enough. Do you think this decision would face a similar negative response, or do you think it would be welcomed by the sports community?
DeleteAlthough there has been improvement in recent years, it is not enough to do away with gender disparity. Seeing the actual percentages of women in leadership positions in the sports world truly puts it into perspective how pressing this issue is. With more female leaders in the sports world creates more change. I think people think that just one woman in a certain role is going to do away with the whole issue. We need to provide equal opportunities for men and women in leadership positions. Gender should not be a deciding factor in the hiring process.
ReplyDelete